rynling: (Default)
Rynling R&D ([personal profile] rynling) wrote2019-01-17 09:48 am
Entry tags:

2019 Resolution #5

I am going to start and finish reading House of Leaves.

This will be the third time I've attempted to read the damn book, but now I have a game plan:

First, I will read the main text, ignoring everything else.

Second, I will read the footnotes, ignoring everything else.

Third, I won't even look at the appendices until I finish reading everything else, and then I'll only read them if I decide that I want to.

I actually admire the structural concept of House of Leaves. One of the main reasons (tbh probably the only reason) I went to grad school and got a PhD is because I genuinely enjoy reading academic writing, and I wish more people structured their fiction like academic writing - or rather, wrote academic books and articles that are entirely fiction.

(One day I will do this myself. I think about it all the time when I'm writing articles and book chapters. Like, what if I just started making things up and went from there? Also, when someone drags me to a museum, I always get an irrational urge to give a "guided tour" based on facts that I invent on the spot, and one of these days I will find a museum friend who doesn't immediately stop me after they figure out what I'm doing.)

(People don't appreciate this about professors, by the way. I could make up literally any garbage I wanted to, put it on a PowerPoint slideshow, give a lecture about it, and then write an actual exam testing students on it. Now that I'm on the other side of the desk, I'm beginning to suspect that a lot of professors do this without thinking, and no one catches them partially because they're considered to be "experts" but mostly because there's very little oversight in most American universities. I don't teach things things that I make up because I have a healthy sense of professional ethics, but sometimes the temptation is strong.)

Anyway, the problem with House of Leaves is that it takes an interesting concept and runs it into the ground in the most obnoxious way possible. I therefore want to finish the book not just because I want to see how it ends but also because I want to study a cautionary example so I won't fuck up the sort of story I want to write.
runicmagitek: (Default)

[personal profile] runicmagitek 2019-01-18 01:04 pm (UTC)(link)
I have a love/hate relationship with this damn book, leaning heavily towards the hate side of things. I can't stand Johnny's narrative at all. I got to a point where I skipped over his sections because I did not care about him or whatever he had to say. I also didn't really like the ending, which... I won't say anything beyond that if you haven't finished it. And while I love the idea of it having footnotes and approaching it as if it were an academic book, it was more distracting for me than intriguing. Then again, I also had a hard time reading textbooks in general in college due to the same thing (I was way better at group discussion and thank god art history was mostly that and reading critiques, reviews, and random articles). I really just wanted it to be a narrative about the spoopy house and not... get lost in all these other things. And it felt more like a chore every time I opened it instead of something I enjoyed reading.

At the same time, I love all the typesetting and formatting. It's a damn work of art. And I love how each page's presentation is taken into consideration for maximize the tone in the narrative. Like no other book has scared the shit out of me more than House of Leaves, strictly because the text itself literally evokes that horror and dread and it's beautiful.

And it makes me upset that a gorgeous horror story is lost in some jerk's ramblings. I still love the concept of House of Leaves, but I could never love House of Leaves, if that makes sense. Regardless, godspeed with finishing it! I'm super curious to hear your thoughts on it, even more so with your insight as an academic.