rynling: (Gator Strut)
I don't ship Reylo because I don't have any particular attachment to the characters or the franchise, but every so often I'll see cute Reylo art or comics that make me smile. The pairing isn't to my taste, but a lot of things aren't, you know? I've blocked people whose work upsets me, but most of the Reylo content I see on Tumblr and Twitter is silly and harmless.

I'm therefore surprised by people who go out of their way to tell everyone that REYLO IS ABUSE, as if someone's stupid Star Wars ship is on the same level as, like, the U.S. Senate confirming Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court.

Honestly, the only thing I hear when someone tries to pass off fandom ship wars as social justice activism is "I don't like it when women have fantasies and tell stories that I do not personally approve of," which really isn't all that different from the misogynistic purity culture of religious fundamentalism.

Thank you for listening.
rynling: (Needs More Zelda)
I recently posted a very short essay in which I expressed discomfort concerning the racist stereotypes used to portray Ganondorf in fanwork and in the Zelda games themselves. I got some intense pushback from unexpected quarters, so I want to attempt to refine and clarify what I was trying to say.

Read more... )

In other words, it's totally normal to have a character who is a villain with dark skin, because expecting characters with dark skin to be perfect while denying them the full range of human experience and emotion is a stupid and ridiculous way to approach representations of racial and ethnic difference. That being said, it's weird and gross to have a character who is a villain BECAUSE he has dark skin.

This all seems obvious to me, which is why I'm surprised that I encounter almost comically racist themes and tropes so frequently in fanwork based on the Zelda games. It's been my experience that fandoms for other video game franchises (like Dragon Age, Borderlands, Final Fantasy, and so on) don't isolate discussions of the more problematic characters from the main fandom, and I can't help but wonder how different Zelda fandom would be if conversations and fanwork portraying its villain characters weren't pushed so far out of the mainstream.
rynling: (Teh Bowz)
I had a strange experience recently, and it's making me feel weird.

There's a guy I recently blocked on Twitter and Tumblr for the normal reasons – he was bothering me and I wanted him to leave me alone. (I wrote about this a bit earlier.)

He sent me some emails in response, but I deleted them unread for, again, the normal reasons – he was bothering me and I didn't want to deal with him.

So then he starts leaving long comments on my fic on AO3.

I felt really attacked. They weren't mean comments, exactly, but...

...but they kind of were. There were a few things he said about my writing that could have been interpreted as positive if they had been coming from a friend but which felt extremely passive-aggressive when coming from someone whose goodwill I don't trust. Also, even if these comments had been entirely positive, it's still emotionally manipulative to try to use public compliments to demand the attention of someone who clearly doesn't want to interact with you.

Now here's the problem – there has always been anxiety at the back of my mind that I'm bothering people by leaving comments on their fic or reblogging their posts with commentary in the tags. It's one thing if I'm throwing love at a stranger, but things start to get awkward if a relationship forms and then becomes one sided. At what point does it become the more respectful and compassionate thing to do to just leave someone alone?

Anyway, I deleted the guy's comments on AO3 and sent him a very short email asking him to fuck off. Of course he sent several emails in response, which I deleted unread because I have no patience for what was undoubtedly sad puppy bullshit, but hopefully this will be the end of it.
rynling: (Default)
This is going to be a long post, so I should probably state my conclusion at the beginning. Here it is: Adult men can be real assholes sometimes. Not all men, of course – some of my best friends are men! – but there's a breed of Woke Liberal Male™ that requires special caution.

Okay, so the thing about rules is that it's cool to bend them, or break them, or change them, or move entirely outside of them, but first you need to know what they are. Personally I like knowing what the rules are so that I can operate within any given environment in an efficient and rational manner, which may or may not involve actually following the rules.

In the case of chaotic and constantly changing social contexts like Tumblr, it can take months or even years to learn the rules. I don't think I understand more than a tiny bit about how Tumblr works, but I've learned a few things in the past six years that I can use to make broad generalizations.

A friend of mine from college joined Tumblr a few months ago, and he is completely clueless regarding how the platform functions. He's clueless in the real world as well, but whatever, that's cool and we love him anyway. And it's fine if he wants to use Tumblr in his own way, because who cares, you know? The problem is that he's getting frustrated that he's not instantly internet famous. He recently asked me for advice, and like a moron I took him at his word and explained three basic rules concerning how Tumblr works.

This was a mistake. Since we were talking about Tumblr, I forgot a basic rule of the real world, which is that One Does Not Offer Advice About Rules To Adult Men.

Read more... )
rynling: (Needs More Zelda)
I've spent the past hour drawing thumbnails for some f/f Zelda pairings I'd like to post pictures of for "Femslash February" on Tumblr, but it's hard.

Last year I got so many messages for so many months from so many people in the Zelda femslash community telling me what a bad person I am and encouraging me to commit suicide. If something like this happens once, it's funny. If it happens a few times, it's just life on the internet. If it happens at least twice a week for eight months, it kind of changes you.

People say that the best way to respond to online harassment is to not respond at all, but this tactic has the unfortunate side effect of making the violence less visible. And then, when you finally do say something, it seems like you're the crazy one for reacting so strongly. When I finally broke down and admitted to a handful of online acquaintances that I was being harassed, they said things like...

"You have to admit that they have a point."

"These people just want to be heard and respected."

"That's rude of them, but you have to understand where they're coming from."

In other words, if the extent of the harassment remains invisible, a culture is created in which the harassers are privileged over the harassed. This is insane, because I'm pretty sure the correct response to a statement like "I'm clinically depressed because I've been receiving death and rape threats every day for weeks" is not "You should think about what you did to deserve this."

At the moment I'm sobbing my eyes out, but I'm hoping this process will be cathartic. And I keep telling myself: It's okay to be gay! It's okay to draw gay girls! It's okay to be in a gay mixed-race relationship! It's okay to draw gay mixed-race relationships! There is nothing wrong with me... except that I kind of suck at drawing.
rynling: (Gator Strut)
This quote from Neil Gaiman (source) has been making the rounds of social media...

What I tend to see happening more and more is people retreating into their own corners. People seem scared to get things wrong or be shouted at so they form villages in which they agree with every other member, and maybe they go out and shout at the people in the next village for fun, but there’s no interchange of ideas going on. I think we have to encourage the idea that you’re allowed to think things. I have thought a great many stupid things over the years, and I can tell you that there’s not one stupid thing that I ever thought where I changed my mind because someone shouted at me or threatened to kill me. On the other hand, having great discussions with good friends, possibly over a drink, has definitely changed my mind and made me try to do better. You’re allowed to do better, but we have to let people do better.

...and, while I don't always agree with everything Gaiman says or does (ironically titling his most recent collection of short stories "Trigger Warning" was kind of a dick move, for example), I tend to agree with him that shouting at people doesn't encourage anyone to change their mind. Personally, as a hardcore advocate of intersectional feminism, I completely understand why people get angry, and like The Incredible Hulk I am always walking around angry myself. Still, I'm not sure what to make of the messages I routinely receive on Tumblr...



...so this is basically how I'm feeling about fandom right now:



(image source)

Profile

rynling: (Default)
Rynling R&D

June 2025

S M T W T F S
1 23456 7
8910 111213 14
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 15th, 2025 03:57 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios