lord of the rings is wholeheartedly earnest in its dedication to portraying hope and love and faith and loyalty and courage, and that is what makes it feel like home to so many of us. it’s true to itself. it doesn’t pretend to be cool and care less. it cares, a lot, and that is a rare, beautiful thing.https://southfarthing.tumblr.com/post/671057084479143936/caffeineheroes-tolkien-knew-we-wouldve-allThis is another wholesome Tolkien post. I don't think sincerity is actually all that rare (Stephen King, for example, is full-on tits-out sincere on every page), but I understand the appeal and transformative potential of happy endings.
In my last post, I mentioned being twenty years old and dating another twenty-year-old who was physically and verbally abusive. That relationship was complicated, and we were both kids. I hope that, as an adult, he's happy and healthy and living his best life. Still, he used to love Lord of the Rings, and the message he took away from it is that things that didn't fit into his worldview were "evil" and thus undeserving of understanding or compassion. I don't think that message is necessarily in the books, in which "difference" is treated with much more nuance, but it's definitely in the Peter Jackson movies.
The Demon King is not sincere, mainly because all of the characters are grown adults who somehow have to live with themselves and the shitty decisions they've made. Still, I want the ending to be happy, and I want it to be happy for everyone. There is no "you've done this one bad thing, and now you're evil and inhuman forever." I want people do the right thing when it's important, and for love to win in the end. After all, what good is time travel if you can't exploit it to get the best ending?